From prodigy.com!GMHV19A Sat Apr 13 12:49:23 1996 Return-Path:Received: by nizkor.almanac.bc.ca (Smail3.1.29.1 #8) id m0u8BJy-000cVSC; Sat, 13 Apr 96 12:49 PDT Received: from pimaia2y.prodigy.com by nizkor.almanac.bc.ca ; 13 APR 96 12:49:14 PDT Received: from mailout2.prodigy.com ([199.4.137.96]) by pimaia2y (8.6.10/8.6.9) with SMTP id PAA27602; Sat, 13 Apr 1996 15:46:00 -0400 Date: Sat, 13 Apr 1996 15:45:36 EDT From: GMHV19A@prodigy.com (MS ANNIE P ALPERT) X-Mailer: PRODIGY Services Company Internet mailer [PIM 3.2-085.43] Message-Id: <096.05890436.GMHV19A@prodigy.com> To: kmcvay@nizkor.almanac.bc.ca, nizkor@nizkor.almanac.bc.ca Subject: Ben Freedman Re: Strom & his garbage Status: RO I've done research on Ben Freedman. I posted a garbled version of my research to alt-revisionism, but here's a copy for reference. BEN FREEDMAN, ARTHUR BUTZ and EMBARRASSED REVISIONISTS This is a pretty convoluted story, but I've tried to present it in logical order: Benjamin Harrison Freedman wrote in a publication, "Common Sense" on May 1, 1959: "On February 22, 1948, the New York Times published figures taken from their 1947 secret census indicating a minimum of 16,150,000 and a maximum of 19,200,000 so-called "Jews" in the world for 1947. Through the courtesy of Mr. Arthur Hays Sulzberger, publisher of the NY Times this author conferred on February 23, 1948 with Commander Baldwin [NOTE: He refers to Hanson Baldwin, military editor of the Times at the time who wrote a weekly column for the Sunday paper -- this will be important later on in this discussion] in his office where this author examined documents fully supporting the figures published by the NY Times on February 22, 1948. This author was allowed to examine the file containing the results of the searching investigations conducted by the NY Times through its own offices throughout the world and with the collaboration of governments and religious bodies in those foreign countries." WHO WAS BEN FREEDMAN, BY THE WAY? Benjamin Harrison Freedman was the originator of the theory that today's Jews are not the descendants of the Jews mentioned in the Bible, but rather descendants of the Khazars, an Asiatic people who occupied Southern Russia (Mongolians, no less) during the seventh century, who had converted to Judiasm. He was born a Jew in New York in 1890, but called himself a fascist and an "honorary Aryan". When WWII broke out he supported of Hitler and predicted Germany would win the war. [More about Freedman and a debunking of the Khazar theory avalable on request.] WHY IS FREEDMAN'S NUMBER IMPORTANT? Ben's number of "a minimum of 16,150,000 and a maximum of 19,200,000" were intended to show that the number of Jews had risen after the war, thus proving the Holocaust death numbers were exaggerated. It was picked up (usually rounded off to 15 to 18 million for some reason) by various Holocaust revisionists over the years. FOR INSTANCE: George Lincoln Rockwell, late Fuehrer of the American Nazi Party, gave an interview to "Playboy" magazine in April, 1966, where cites Hanson's figures--but just the higher one (18 million) -- Then he adds the 6 million Jews exterminated by Hitler, and comes up with a total of 24 million world Jewish population for 1948. He compares 24 million with the 1939 World Almanac figure for world Jewish population: 15,688,259 in an attempt to prove that 8,311,741 Jews appeared on the planet between 1939 and 1948. Another (more relavant) example: In 1976, Arthur Butz wrote "The Hoax of the 20th Century"--a book that supposes that the Holocaust is a Zionist plot and that 6,000,000 Jews did not die at the hands of the Nazis. In that book, in a discussion of pre- and post-war population figures (p 13) Butz stated: "Hanson Baldwin, N.Y. Times Military expert, in an article written in 1948 dealing with the then forthcoming Arab-Jewish war on the basis of information available at the UN and other places, gave a figure of 15 to 18 million world Jewish population, as well as figures for such things as Jews in Palestine, Jews in the Middle East, Arabs in Palestine, total Arabs, total Moslems,etc. (footnote 6)." Hanson's 02/22/48 article (NY Times, page 4) was entitled "Armies for Palestine: Need for International Force of 70,000 Believed Indicated as U. N. Faces Decision" (this was an article about a possible Arab-Israeli war). Buried in the text was this: ". . . The Jewish areas of Palestine are an enclave surrounded by Arabs. There are 650,000 to 700,000 Jews in Palestine and about 1,250,000 Arabs. Another 500,000 Jews inhabit other Arab countries in the Middle East. The Arab population these states, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen and Trans-Jordan, is more than 30,000,000. In these countries, the Jews are tied by bonds of religion to the rest of the fifteen to eighteen million Jews of the world, and most of the Arabs share their religion with the rest of the world's 221,000,000 Moslems..." [NOTE: in context, we see that while Baldwin provides literal numbers for the various population figures (i.e. 1,250,000), he gives figurative numbers (i.e. "fifteen to eighteen million") for the estimated population of Jews. It would seem he didn't think it was important to get the number exact for this article. Ironically, he was trying to show how FEW Jews there were compared to Moslems, but that's another story.] Getting back to Mr. Freedman. Remember his "secret census", his visit with Mr. Sulzberger and Mr. Baldwin, and his search through a "file containing the results of the searching investigations conducted by the NY Times through its own offices throughout the world and with the collaboration of governments and religious bodies in those foreign countries"? NOTE: Mr Freedman says he went to the Times office on Mon. Feb 23 (the paper came out on Sunday, Feb 22). Pretty fast footwork, no? WHAT ELSE DO WE KNOW ABOUT THIS AFFAIR? Morris Kominsky, author of "Hoaxers" (Branden Press, 1970) [NOTE: this is BEFORE Butz's publication date of 1976], wrote a letter to Mr. Balwin and recieved the following reply: "Dear Mr. Kominsky, "Thank you for your letter of inquiry of January 6. "The world Jewish population figures printed in this story came from the 1948 edition of the World Almanac. Later we checked it with the American Jewish Committee and other sources and said in the correction, as I noted to you in my previous letter, that the authorities agree that Hitler's wholesale massacre of Jews during the war reduced the Jewish population to perhaps 12 million today (2/26/48). "If Mr. Freedman met with me I do not remember it. The problem is of course, that you are talking about events that took place 19 years ago. I see hundreds of people per year, many of them only for a few minutes so I could not swear that I did not see Mr. Freedman but if I did it made no impression either upon me or upon my assistant. "I do not know what Mr. Freedman means by examination of documents but to my knowledge we had no particular documents bearing on the issue in question. "I hope this answers your questions; if there is anything else you wish to know please do not hesitate to write again. "Sincerely, Hanson W. Baldwin (Military Editor)" IN SUMMATION: There was no "secret census", no "file containing the results of the searching investigations conducted by the NY Times through its own offices throughout the world and with the collaboration of governments and religious bodies in those foreign countries". Just a beleagered ex-military man appointed editor who looked up some numbers in an almanac. Mr. Freedman, in his eagerness to prove a point, unwittingly caused a chain reaction of errors that were perpetuated by people who didn't bother to check the facts. A lot of times, when I'm verifying claims made by revisionists and racists, I find errors, quotes out of context and selective presentation of data. It's hard to take the revisionist postion seriously when it's this easy to debunk the basic tenents
Home ·
Site Map ·
What's New? ·
Search
Nizkor
© The Nizkor Project, 1991-2012
This site is intended for educational purposes to teach about the Holocaust and
to combat hatred.
Any statements or excerpts found on this site are for educational purposes only.
As part of these educational purposes, Nizkor may
include on this website materials, such as excerpts from the writings of racists and antisemites. Far from approving these writings, Nizkor condemns them and
provides them so that its readers can learn the nature and extent of hate and antisemitic discourse. Nizkor urges the readers of these pages to condemn racist
and hate speech in all of its forms and manifestations.