A later version of this same letter has recently been posted at the CODOH site: http://www.codoh.com/review/revhslresp1.html . No response is present at present (12/20/96). From: Dene BebbingtonNewsgroups: alt.revisionism Subject: Letter to Greg Raven regarding his IHR web pages Date: Tue, 5 Nov 1996 23:57:33 +0000 Lines: 48 Message-ID: X-Mail2News-User: dene@bebbo.demon.co.uk X-Mail2News-Path: relay-7.mail.demon.net!relay-5.mail.demon.net!bebbo.demon.co.uk MIME-Version: 1.0 X-Mailer: Turnpike Version 3.01 I attach here a letter I have recently emailed to Greg Raven regarding the essay written by Michael Hoffman (from a longer piece rather pathetically called "Swindler's Mist") that appears on his IHR pages. Greg Raven pledges on his page to change anything that is untrue, so I look forward with interest to his response to this letter. The information I cite regarding the Talmud books comes from responses to a question of mine posted in soc.culture.jewish. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Greg, I have a further point to raise regarding the essay by Michael Hoffman on "Schindler's List" that appears on your IHR Web pages, the section of the essay I refer to is as follows: >>>>> We are told that the inscription is from the Talmud, "He who saves a single life, saves the entire world." (This quotation also appears on posters advertising Schindler's List in video stores and schools, apparently having been selected as the film's motto by its promoters). The saying has a nice, warm, humanistic tenor, but there's just one problem: that's not what the Talmud says. The actual Talmud verse states, "Whosoever preserves a single soul of Israel, Scripture ascribes to him as if he had preserved a complete world" (Tractate Sanhedrin 37a). The Talmud only praises the saving of Jewish lives. In Spielberg's non-stop deception, even the documented contents of Jewish books are falsified. <<<<< To my knowledge this accusation of falsification is simply wrong. Both quotes appear in different Talmud books, the first quote "He who saves a single life, saves the entire world." apparently comes from the Talmud Yerushalmi (Sanhedrin 4:9), whilst the other quote "Whosoever preserves a single soul of Israel, Scripture ascribes to him as if he had preserved a complete world" comes from the Talmud Bavli (Bava Batra 11a and elsewhere). It is true that Jewish people consider the Talmud Bavli more authoritative, but nevertheless it is wrong to state that Spielberg is falsifying the contents of Jewish books in this particular case. -- Dene Bebbington Path: news.voyager.net!aanews.merit.net!news.cic.net!newsrelay.netins.net!newsfeed.dacom.co.kr!usenet.kornet.nm.kr!howland.erols.net!panix!feed1.news.erols.com!news.idt.net!newsfeed.internetmci.com!btnet!dispatch.news.demon.net!demon!bebbo.demon.co.uk!dene From: Dene Bebbington Newsgroups: alt.revisionism Subject: Re: Letter to Greg Raven regarding his IHR web pages Date: Mon, 11 Nov 1996 23:11:22 +0000 Organization: Deno's Domicile Lines: 56 Distribution: world Message-ID: References: NNTP-Posting-Host: bebbo.demon.co.uk X-NNTP-Posting-Host: bebbo.demon.co.uk MIME-Version: 1.0 X-Newsreader: Turnpike Version 3.01 I've read elsewhere that Greg Raven is involved in some lawsuits regarding the IHR, and this may explain his lack of response so far, although no response has been forthcoming from Michael Hoffman who is the author of the _Schindler's List_ article. But as a reminder, here it is again. Posted, and emailed to Greg Raven & Michael Hoffman. Dene Bebbington wrote: >I attach here a letter I have recently emailed to Greg Raven regarding >the essay written by Michael Hoffman (from a longer piece rather >pathetically called "Swindler's Mist") that appears on his IHR pages. >Greg Raven pledges on his page to change anything that is untrue, so I >look forward with interest to his response to this letter. > >The information I cite regarding the Talmud books comes from responses >to a question of mine posted in soc.culture.jewish. > >----------------------------------------------------------------------- >Greg, > >I have a further point to raise regarding the essay by Michael Hoffman >on "Schindler's List" that appears on your IHR Web pages, the section of >the essay I refer to is as follows: > >>>>>> > We are told that the inscription is from the Talmud, "He who saves a >single life, saves the entire world." (This quotation also appears on >posters advertising Schindler's List in video stores and schools, >apparently having been selected as the film's motto by its promoters). > >The saying has a nice, warm, humanistic tenor, but there's just one >problem: that's not what the Talmud says. The actual Talmud verse >states, "Whosoever preserves a single soul of Israel, Scripture ascribes >to him as if he had preserved a complete world" (Tractate Sanhedrin >37a). The Talmud only praises the saving of Jewish lives. In Spielberg's >non-stop deception, even the documented contents of Jewish books are >falsified. ><<<<< > >To my knowledge this accusation of falsification is simply wrong. Both >quotes appear in different Talmud books, the first quote "He who saves a >single life, saves the entire world." apparently comes from the Talmud >Yerushalmi (Sanhedrin 4:9), whilst the other quote "Whosoever preserves >a single soul of Israel, Scripture ascribes to him as if he had >preserved a complete world" comes from the Talmud Bavli (Bava Batra 11a >and elsewhere). > >It is true that Jewish people consider the Talmud Bavli more >authoritative, but nevertheless it is wrong to state that Spielberg is >falsifying the contents of Jewish books in this particular case. > >-- >Dene Bebbington Path: news.voyager.net!nntp.netrex.net!gatech!www.nntp.primenet.com!nntp.primenet.com!EU.net!usenet2.news.uk.psi.net!uknet!usenet1.news.uk.psi.net!uknet!dispatch.news.demon.net!demon!bebbo.demon.co.uk!dene From: Dene Bebbington Newsgroups: alt.revisionism Subject: Re: Letter to Greg Raven regarding his IHR web pages Date: Wed, 20 Nov 1996 19:06:11 +0000 Organization: Deno's Domicile Lines: 76 Distribution: world Message-ID: References: NNTP-Posting-Host: bebbo.demon.co.uk X-NNTP-Posting-Host: bebbo.demon.co.uk MIME-Version: 1.0 X-Newsreader: Turnpike Version 3.01 Still no reply, I wonder which of the following is the most plausible: 1. Both Greg Raven and Michael Hoffman are too busy to answer my email sent over 2 weeks ago. 2. Neither of them has come up with a good excuse yet. 3. They're doing their homework and checking the facts before responding. 4. They haven't any response, but don't wish to admit the error (whether deliberate or otherwise). Dene Bebbington wrote: >Still no reply from either Greg Raven or Michael Hoffman. > > >Dene Bebbington wrote: >>I've read elsewhere that Greg Raven is involved in some lawsuits >>regarding the IHR, and this may explain his lack of response so far, >>although no response has been forthcoming from Michael Hoffman who is >>the author of the _Schindler's List_ article. But as a reminder, here it >>is again. >> >>Posted, and emailed to Greg Raven & Michael Hoffman. >> >> >>Dene Bebbington wrote: >>>I attach here a letter I have recently emailed to Greg Raven regarding >>>the essay written by Michael Hoffman (from a longer piece rather >>>pathetically called "Swindler's Mist") that appears on his IHR pages. >>>Greg Raven pledges on his page to change anything that is untrue, so I >>>look forward with interest to his response to this letter. >>> >>>The information I cite regarding the Talmud books comes from responses >>>to a question of mine posted in soc.culture.jewish. >>> >>>----------------------------------------------------------------------- >>>Greg, >>> >>>I have a further point to raise regarding the essay by Michael Hoffman >>>on "Schindler's List" that appears on your IHR Web pages, the section of >>>the essay I refer to is as follows: >>> >>>>>>>> >>> We are told that the inscription is from the Talmud, "He who saves a >>>single life, saves the entire world." (This quotation also appears on >>>posters advertising Schindler's List in video stores and schools, >>>apparently having been selected as the film's motto by its promoters). >>> >>>The saying has a nice, warm, humanistic tenor, but there's just one >>>problem: that's not what the Talmud says. The actual Talmud verse >>>states, "Whosoever preserves a single soul of Israel, Scripture ascribes >>>to him as if he had preserved a complete world" (Tractate Sanhedrin >>>37a). The Talmud only praises the saving of Jewish lives. In Spielberg's >>>non-stop deception, even the documented contents of Jewish books are >>>falsified. >>><<<<< >>> >>>To my knowledge this accusation of falsification is simply wrong. Both >>>quotes appear in different Talmud books, the first quote "He who saves a >>>single life, saves the entire world." apparently comes from the Talmud >>>Yerushalmi (Sanhedrin 4:9), whilst the other quote "Whosoever preserves >>>a single soul of Israel, Scripture ascribes to him as if he had >>>preserved a complete world" comes from the Talmud Bavli (Bava Batra 11a >>>and elsewhere). >>> >>>It is true that Jewish people consider the Talmud Bavli more >>>authoritative, but nevertheless it is wrong to state that Spielberg is >>>falsifying the contents of Jewish books in this particular case. >>> >>>-- >>>Dene Bebbington >> > Path: news.voyager.net!aanews.merit.net!news.izzy.net!news.good.net!news.good.net!www.nntp.primenet.com!nntp.primenet.com!feed1.news.erols.com!howland.erols.net!EU.net!usenet2.news.uk.psi.net!uknet!usenet1.news.uk.psi.net!uknet!dispatch.news.demon.net!demon!bebbo.demon.co.uk!dene From: Dene Bebbington Newsgroups: alt.revisionism Subject: Re: Israeli Court Values Palestinian Life at One-Third of a Cent Date: Sat, 23 Nov 1996 18:09:16 +0000 Organization: Deno's Domicile Lines: 101 Distribution: world Message-ID: References: <19961119192600.OAA28167@ladder01.news.aol.com> <32941585.440882@199.0.216.204> <3293f02a.245526725@news.micron.net> <32956ef6.932187@199.0.216.204> NNTP-Posting-Host: bebbo.demon.co.uk X-NNTP-Posting-Host: bebbo.demon.co.uk MIME-Version: 1.0 X-Newsreader: Turnpike Version 3.01 tom moran wrote: >>On Wed, 20 Nov 1996 14:49:23 -0500, jamie@voyager.net (Jamie McCarthy) >>wrote: >> >>>tm@pacificnet.net (tom moran) wrote: >>> >>>> Talmud: >>>> >>>> "He who so ever sould save the life of a Jew, is as if he saved >>>> the life of the whole world." >>>> >>>> Inversely, 'He who so ever saves the life of a goy, is as if he >>>> saved nothing.' >>> >>>This has been debunked already. > Jamie McCarthy is always claiming something has been "debunked". >The only thing he ever debunks is himself. I attach a copy of an email I received in response to a question about this Talmudic quotation, this email was a Cc of a public posting: ----------------------------------------------------------------------- This question came up some time ago on scj. I cannot find my original post on the subject in my files, so I will reproduce it in brief. The source for this saying is in the Mishnah, Sanhedrin 4:5. It appears in several versions: 1. In the standard edition of the Mishnayot, the wording is: "Whoever destroys the life of a single human being [nefesh a`hat mi-bnei adam] ... it is as if he had destroyed an entire world; and whoever preserves the life of a single human being ... it is as if he had preserved an entire world". 2. In the Talmud Bavli, where this mishnah appears on Sanhedrin 37a, the wording is the same, except for the substitution of "life of a single Jew" [nefesh a`hat \mi-yisrael] for "life of a single human being". 3. In the Talmud Jerushalmi, Mishnah 5 is divided into subsections (Halakhot). In my edition the saying appears in Halakhot 12-13. Others divide Mishnah 5 differently: e.g. MTR locates it in Halakhah 9. It reads "destroys a single life" [ma'abed nefesh a`hat] and "preserves a single life" [meqayem nefesh a`hat]. There is no specific mention of either "human being" or "Jew", though the former is clearly implied. The question is: Which is the original version? Was the limitation to Jewish lives there to begin with, and then taken out as a result of Church censorship? This is suggested in the book of corrigenda, Hesronot Ha-shas. Alternatively, was the universal formulation the original one, and the limitation to Jewish lives introduced into it at some later date, perhaps in a period when particularly severe persecution of Jews generated a justified feeling of xenophobia? The answer would seem to be obvious from the context, which is the same in all three versions. The citation is preceded by the words: "This is why Adam was created alone. It is to teach us that ...". A bit father down it reads: "When a man mints a number of coins from a single die, they are all identical; but the King of the kings of kings, the Holy One blessed be He, minted every human being from the die of the primal Adam, and not one of them is like any other". Evidently, if the original had referred to the preservation of Jewish lives alone, the reference would have been to Abraham at the earliest. The repeated reference to Adam, progenitor of all mankind, makes it clear that the original must have referred to the preservation of human life in general. This is aparently how the Rishonim (medieval commentators) understood it as well. Rambam adopts the Yerushalmi version, (3.) slightly altered, in Hilkhot Sanhedrin 12:3, but also cites the Bavli version (2. above) briefly in Hilkhot Rotzea`h 1:6. Hameiri too bases his commentary on the Yerushalmi version, illustrating "the destruction of a whole world" by pointing out that Cain's murder of Abel eliminated all of his victm's descendents at one fell swoop. Abel, like Adam was not Jewish; he was not even the ancestor of Jews. The humanistic version was not universally accepted by the A`haronim (later commentators). MaHaRSh"A, for example, in Hidushei Agadot on Sanh.37a, stays with Version 2, and explains at some length why it is only important to save Jewish lives, even though the Mishnah bases the dictum on Adam's being the father of all mankind. I would be interested in learning what present-day Orthodox Judaism regards as the authentic reading. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- -- Dene Bebbington "... after all, who'd notice another madman around here?!"
Home ·
Site Map ·
What's New? ·
Search
Nizkor
© The Nizkor Project, 1991-2012
This site is intended for educational purposes to teach about the Holocaust and
to combat hatred.
Any statements or excerpts found on this site are for educational purposes only.
As part of these educational purposes, Nizkor may
include on this website materials, such as excerpts from the writings of racists and antisemites. Far from approving these writings, Nizkor condemns them and
provides them so that its readers can learn the nature and extent of hate and antisemitic discourse. Nizkor urges the readers of these pages to condemn racist
and hate speech in all of its forms and manifestations.